Friday, September 7, 2012

Response to Political Speeches


The speeches made by Michelle Obama and Ann Romney were very much alike, but they had a few differences.  In the end, both of these women have the same goal in mind and that is to get their husbands as much support as possible.  Both ladies did a wonderful job of bringing emotional appeal to their speeches and including numerous examples of pathos.  The speeches were very similar in the ways that both ladies talked about the importance of family.  Ann Romney focused more on the effect women have on society and how important it is to be a good mother.  At one point she said that women hold the country together.  Michelle Obama on the other hand focused more on family as a whole.  She spoke about how your past can influence your future, but only you determine whether it’s a good or bad outcome.  She states that even if you don’t start out with much, you can work hard and build a decent life for yourself, and an even better life for your kids.  Both ladies included a few examples of logos relating to their own lives, and only a couple examples of ethos.  Considering the speech they were giving and who they were addressing, more emotional appeal is necessary in order to capture the attention of your audience.  Watching the two of these videos makes it very hard to critique them without putting your own political opinion into it.  I tried watching the two speeches with an open mind, but it still makes it difficult to compare the two videos without choosing one that you prefer more.  The audience reactions actually make a huge impact on how I viewed the two speeches.  It was very interesting to see which speech got more credibility from the audience, and which parts of the speeches were appealing to them.  Emotional appeal is probably the most important thing in speeches like the two of these, and both women definitely did a good job in grabbing the attention of the audience.  They both made very good speeches, and it ends up coming down to personal opinions as to which one you preferred.  

No comments:

Post a Comment